STOOTHOFF HOUSE
494 Jamaica Avenue
Often we rode past the house and never realized that we were looking at
an ancient dwelling so completely has its exterior been changed. Suddenly one
day we noticed the slope of its roof and stopped to examine it. It was the
typically New Netherland Dutch overshot roof. At the top near its ridgepole
were two old bull's eyes.
We rang: the bell of this intriguing house. Its owner did not know when
it was built nor to whom it had originally belonged. He said he knew it was an
old house because there were huge aged beams in its cellar and garret and great
open fireplaces in two of its rooms.
Later we discovered that the land on which it stood belonged to Jan BARENTS
BLOOM back in the eighteenth century and that early in the nineteenth it was sold
to Wilhelmus STOOTHOFF. It extended from the Jamaica Road south to the New Lots Road.
But we could not learn who built the house or when.
In John Baxter's diary are the notations:
Aug. 13, 1800. Raised barn for Bill STOOTHOFF on Jamaica Road in New Lots.
April 10, 1814. Hear that Bill STOOTHOFF's house at New Lots
was robbed of $140.
Bill was the Wilhelmus STOOTHOFF, son of Wilhelmus STOOTHOFF and Heiltie VOORHIES,
who was born in Flatlands 20 November 1768. He married Arabelle or Anabelle PETTIT
21 December 1799 and probably acquired the New Lots property about that time. He may
have built the house upon it although it appears to be of an earlier date and it would
seem that Baxter would have mentioned the fact.
Bill and Arabelle had a son Stephen whose child Joseph is buried in the New Lots Cemetery.
They had a son William who married Sarah, daughter of John C. STOOTHOFF of Jamaica South.
William had a son William who was born 28 April 1849 and who married Emeline E. DURYEA.
Bill STOOTHOFF died 10 August 1837. Previous to his death, he had sold his farm to
John R. PITKIN of Connecticut who planned the real estate development of East New York
for that locality.
The panic of 1837 resulted in the farm reverting to the STOOTHOFF. Bill's son William
was its next owner. Sometime after the Civil War, William's heirs sold the house and forty
acres of land to Edward F. LINTON of Massachusetts. In 1889, LINTON sold the house to
Frank HART who remodelled it. Later it became the property of Henry CYR, a Swiss, who
lives in half of it and rents the other half. '
Bill STOOTHOFF's parents were married in Flatlands in December, 1762. His father
Wilhelmus (b.3 May 1741 - d.21 September1803) was the son of Wilhelmus STOOTHOFF of Flatlands
and Altie VOORHIES who were married November 1728.
The last named Wilhelmus was the son of Elbert STOOTHOFF (b.1685 - d. 1756) who married
Johanna LUPARDUS 28 March 1714.
Elbert's parents were Gerret STOOTHOFF (baptized 11 March 1668 - d. 1734) and Johanna NEVIUS.
His grandfather, Elbert ELBERTSEN, was a farmer's boy of ten or eleven years when he emigrated
from Nieuw Kercken in North Brabant about 1637 in the employ of the patroon Killaen VAN RENSSELLAER.
Elbert ELBERTSEN spent some time at Fort Orange (Albany) and then settled in Amersfoort
where he married Altie COOL, widow of Gerret Wolphertsen van COUWENHOVEN, 24 August 1645, and
assumed the management of Gerret's property on condition that he pay Gerret's debts and educate
his four children.
In 1648, he was one of the nine men appointed to help the Director General and his Council
promote the welfare of the Province.
After the surrender of New Netherland to the English, he took the oath of allegiance and
added the surname of STOOTHOFF to his Elbert ELBERTSEN. He was made a captain in the local militia.
He dealt in real estate, and became one of the largest landowners in Kings County. Also he kept
store in his home in Flatlands and his account books are now the property of the Long Island
Historical Society. He died about 1681.
His children were :
Elbert (who died in infancy),
Gerret,
Heiltie (who married Thomas WILLET) and
Achye or Aegge (wife of Jan VAN DUCKHUYS).
Next Chapter..DURYEA HOUSE
DUTCH Houses..Index Main
Return to TOWN Index Main
Return to BROOKLYN Index Main